Recent Cases

Alamin v Islam [2023] NSWCA 326 (20 December 2023) (White JA and Simpson AJA)


Catchwords:


APPEALS – Leave to appeal – Leave to appeal from costs orders following dismissal of application for mandatory interlocutory injunctive relief – Where parties entered into deed settling litigation in Equity Division – Where applicant covenanted to pay $3.25m to respondent in tranches – Where applicant charged shares in related company as security for payments due under deed – Where applicant subsequently sought rectification of deed and release of charge over shares or a declaration the deed was void ab initio by reason of mistake – Where mistake said to generate equity of rectification as to effect of granting charge on other financing arrangements between parties – Whether primary judge erred in refusing mandatory interlocutory injunctive relief against respondent – Whether applicant had identified question of principle of general importance or injustice or error going beyond one merely arguable – No issue of principle – Leave to appeal refused