Recent Cases

Daynes v I-Med Central Queensland Pty Ltd; I-Med Central Queensland Pty Ltd v Daynes [2025] NSWCA 150 (11 July 2025) (Bell CJ, Leeming and Free JJA)


Catchwords:


CONTRACT – contract – summary dismissal – allegations of sexual harassment and workplace bullying – whether Appellant engaged in a “haka” or a pelvic thrust – where conduct relied upon to found summary dismissal held not be established

COSTS – Calderbank offer – where successful party did not “better” financial terms of offer by unsuccessful defendant made shortly prior to trial – relevance of issues going to public vindication in assessing reasonableness of rejection of offer – where argument going to this issue inadvertently overlooked – nature of judgment awarding of costs – even if matter dealt with summarily, key arguments need to be addressed

DAMAGES – contract of employment – where conduct relied upon to found summary dismissal held not to be established – whether employer would have terminated employment following expiry of fixed term of employment on three months’ notice under termination without cause provisions in circumstances where employee had elected to continue employment following expiry of fixed term – proper basis for assessment of damages in such circumstances – loss of a chance or balance of probabilities

EMPLOYMENT LAW – contract of employment – summary dismissal – allegations of sexual harassment and workplace bullying – whether Appellant engaged in a “haka” or a pelvic thrust – where conduct relied upon to found summary dismissal held not be established