Recent Cases

DHI22 v Qatar Airways Group QCSC (No 1) [2025] FCAFC 91 (24 July 2025) (Mortimer CJ; Stewart and Stellios JJ)


Catchwords:


AVIATION – carriers’ liability – where applicants had boarded flight at Doha airport bound for Sydney – where aircraft had been waiting at gate for hours – where applicants allege that all women passengers were directed to leave the aircraft – where four applicants allege that they endured bodily inspections and three applicants allege invasive examinations by a “nurse” in an ambulance on airport tarmac – where applicants subsequently returned to aircraft which eventually departed Doha and reached Sydney – whether claim can be brought against carrier under Art 17 of the Montreal Convention – temporal scope of Art 17 – meaning of “in the course of any of the operations of embarking or disembarking”

AVIATION – scope of exclusivity principle in Art 29 of the Montreal Convention – whether, if accident not held to be “in the course of any of the operations of embarking or disembarking”, applicants are precluded from bringing common law claims in negligence against carrier – whether temporal scope of exclusivity principle is coextensive with Art 17 – whether “international carriage by air” is broader than Art 17

NEGLIGENCE – where applicants assert alternative case in negligence against carrier – where “second limb” of negligence case is that the carrier failed to take steps to protect the applicants from harm once directed off the aircraft – where primary judge held that “second limb” of negligence claim had no reasonable prospects of success – whether any basis on which duty of care could extend to the risk of harm independently of embarking or disembarking the aircraft – whether applicants have a more than fanciful prospect of being able to plead facts that disclose cause of action

TORTS – where applicants assert claims in negligence, assault, false imprisonment and battery against airport operator – where applicants seek to attribute liability for actions of “nurse” to airport operator – whether nurse employed by operator or in a relationship of “true agency” – where applicants allege that airport operator owed duty of care covering acts occurring inside ambulance on tarmac – whether scope of duty extends to the circumstances in and around the ambulance

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where carrier granted summary judgment on the basis that the accident was outside the temporal scope of Art 17 of the Montreal Convention – whether temporal scope of Art 17 suitable for summary judgment – where question involves arguable questions of fact and degree – question inappropriate for summary determination

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where primary judge granted limited leave to the applicants to re-plead and in effect struck out various parts of the claim against the airport operator – where primary judge concluded that claims alleging that operator was vicariously liable for actions of the “nurse” and that the scope of the operator’s duty of care extended to events in the ambulance had no prospects of success – whether applicants should have leave to amend pleadings in relation to claims against operator