Recent Cases

Elhawat v Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer [2025] NSWCA 88 (05 May 2025) (Ward P, Adamson and Ball JJA)


Catchwords:


INSURANCE – claim for work injury damages – pre-filing procedures under Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (NSW) – where employer failed to serve pre-filing defence – where employer subsequently filed defence raising contributory negligence – where s 318(1)(c) prevents employer from filing a defence that wholly or partly disputes liability for the claim if employer has failed to serve a pre-filing defence – whether “wholly or partly disputes liability” includes raising a defence of contributory negligence – whether contributory negligence is an aspect of liability or damages – contributory negligence an aspect of liability – employer barred from raising contributory negligence – defence struck out

STATUTORY INTERPRETATION – meaning of “wholly or partly disputes liability” – where statutory note in s 318A(2) in tension with plain interpretation of s 318 – where primary judge had regard to note in s 318A(2) – whether statutory note forms part of the Act – note not part of the Act – note may be considered as extrinsic material – note cannot displace the correct meaning of the section