Recent Cases

Health Care Complaints Commission v Hill [2022] NSWCA 270 (15 December 2022) (Ward P, Mitchelmore JA and Basten AJA)


Catchwords:


OCCUPATIONS – health practitioners – misconduct and discipline – disciplinary proceedings – Director of Proceedings’ decision to commence NCAT disciplinary proceedings – application alleging unsatisfactory professional conduct and professional misconduct – whether allegations of professional misconduct were legally unreasonable

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – reviewability – grounds of review – subject matter of power or decision – prosecutorial decision – whether Director of Proceedings’ decision should be treated as final – statutory interpretation – prosecutorial powers largely immune from judicial review but subject to NCAT control – legislature did not intend Court to determine which applications may be considered by specialist tribunal – decision is non-justiciable

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – remedies – certiorari –decision to refer complaint had no effect on medical practitioner’s legal rights – no power to make fact findings or affect registration – no relief in certiorari

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – remedies – discretionary factors – failure to make strike out application in NCAT – discretion to refuse relief