Recent Cases

IWC Industries Pty Ltd v Sergienko [2021] NSWCA 292 (01 December 2021) (Bathurst CJ, Ward and Gleeson JJA)


Catchwords:


EQUITY – equitable interests in real property – priorities – where property purchased by trustee on trust for sole unitholder – competing claims of beneficiary under trust and equitable mortgagee – where beneficiary did not pay any monies towards purchase price of property or “fully paid” units in unit trust – where beneficiary’s solicitor advised trustee was untrustworthy – where trust deed conferred wide powers on trustee, including power to mortgage trust assets for any contractual obligation – where trust deed precluded unitholder from lodging caveat against any trust property and no caveat was lodged – where equitable mortgage granted over property to respondent in breach of trust – whether merits of competing equities unequal – whether beneficiary’s prior interest postponed to subsequent interest of equitable mortgagee

EQUITY – equitable interests in real property – priorities – where unitholder issued “fully paid” units but no monies paid for units in trust or towards purchase of property – whether evidence that trustee borrowed funds for purchase of property – whether beneficiary has liability to trustee for units issued to it – whether beneficiary was a volunteer