Recent Cases

Karpik v Carnival plc (The Ruby Princess) [2025] FCAFC 96 (29 July 2025) (Markovic, Sarah C Derrington and Jackson JJ)


Catchwords:


CONSUMER LAW – cross-appeal – purpose guarantee in s 61(1) and result guarantee in s 61(2) of the Australian Consumer Law (ACL) – alleged error in finding that purpose and result of acquiring services was to have a “safe, relaxing and pleasurable cruise” – potential overlap of purpose guarantee and result guarantee – grounds of cross-appeal not made out

CONSUMER LAW – cross-appeal – alleged error in finding breaches of purpose and result guarantees – compliance with guarantees is an objective test – inferences from facts and events before and after supply of services are permissible – grounds of cross-appeal not made out

CONSUMER LAW – cross-appeal – s 267(4) of the ACL – causation of loss from breaches of purpose and result guarantees – alleged error in refraining from analysing each specific shortcoming in the services provided – grounds of cross-appeal not made out

CONSUMER LAW – scope of guarantee – due care and skill guarantee in s 60 of the ACL – alleged error in finding of failure to supply services with due care and skill – grounds of cross-appeal not made out

NEGLIGENCE – cross-appeal – scope of duty of care –alleged error in finding that owner and operators of passenger vessel owe a duty of care to passengers to care for their health and safety including in relation to the risk of harm caused by infectious disease – grounds of cross-appeal not made out

NEGLIGENCE – cross-appeal – breach of duty of care – alleged error in finding that the respondents had breached their duty of care owed to the applicant – consideration of precautions a reasonable person in respondents’ position would have taken – grounds of cross-appeal not made out

DAMAGES – where personal injuries suffered were COVID-19 infection and associated adjustment disorder – consideration of availability and assessment of distress and disappointment damages – where appellant received a full refund of cost of cruise holiday – whether refund properly a credit against distress and disappointment damages – grounds of appeal not made out

DAMAGES – personal injury damages for non-economic loss – alleged error in assessment of severity of non-economic loss assessed against a most extreme case – grounds of appeal not made out