Recent Cases

MMP Industrial Pty Ltd and MMP NZ Ltd v Yaem Pty Ltd as trustee for the R & R Discretionary Trust [2026] NSWCA 229 (29 October 2026) (Stern and McHugh JJA, Black J)


Catchwords:


APPEALS — leave to appeal — principles governing — where no question of general importance raised by application — where no reason to think primary judge did not properly apply apparent relevance test to subpoena — where neither necessary nor desirable to address question of appropriate standard of appellate review — where primary judge’s decision was not unjust and does not warrant appellate intervention — application for leave to appeal dismissed

CIVIL PROCEDURE — subpoenas — application to set aside

APPEALS — where proposed grounds of appeal as to failure to give reasons, failure to apply correct principle to setting aside subpoena and House v King error in discretion raised