Recent Cases

oOh!media Fly Pty Ltd v Transport for NSW [2024] NSWCA 200 (15 August 2024) (Leeming, Kirk and Adamson JJA)


Catchwords:


VALUATION – Compensation for compulsory acquisition of strip of land used for road to Sydney Airport – Market value – Procedural fairness in rejecting valuation method proposed – Notice of basis of rejection – Issue raised both in submissions and on the facts – Running commentary on submissions not required

VALUATION – Market value – Statutory disregard of change in value caused by public purpose – Challenge partly overtaken by subsequent case law – No disregard for change in value resulting from owner’s free choice due to suspected acquisition

VALUATION – Special value and disturbance – Tax gross up – Issue not raised – No basis for criticism for failing to give reasons with respect to claim not made

APPEALS – Jurisdiction of appellate court – Appeal from Land and Environment Court – Question of law – Claimed constructive failure to exercise jurisdiction to make allowance for potentialities – Matter not put as part of appellant’s case below – Complex factual issue necessitating further evidence – No constructive failure – In substance appellant had been seeking to reopen its case