Recent Cases

Roberts Co (NSW) Pty Ltd v Sharvain Facades Pty Ltd (Administrators Appointed) [2025] NSWCA 161 (23 July 2025) (Hammerschlag CJ in Eq, McHugh JA and Griffiths AJA)


Catchwords:


BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION — Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) (the Act) ss 13, 14 and 31 — a written construction contract between the parties provides that if a payment claim under s 13 is made by email after 5:00pm on a business day it is deemed to have been received at 9:00am on the next business day (the Deeming Clause) — s 14 of the Act provides that if a payment schedule in response to service of a payment claim is not provided by the respondent to the claimant within the time provided by the relevant construction contract or within 10 business days of the time it is served, whichever time expires earlier, the respondent is liable to pay the amount claimed — the payment claim was served after business hours on Friday 28 February 2025 and the payment schedule was provided on 17 March 2025 — if the Deeming Clause operated to deem service of the payment claim to have been on the next business day ie. 3 March 2025, the payment schedule was within 10 business days of that day, but if service took place on 28 February 2025 it was out of time — HELD — service of the payment claim took place on Friday 28 February 2025 — the Deeming Clause did not operate to change that time for service to 3 March 2025 because on its proper construction s 14 of the Act permits the parties to agree a shorter period for service of a payment schedule than 10 business days from service of the payment claim but not a longer period — the payment schedule provided was out of time and the respondent became liable to pay the amount of the payment claim