Recent Cases

Southern Cross Payments Ltd v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2026] FCAFC 140 (02 November 2026) (Stewart, Cheeseman and Neskovcin JJ)


Catchwords:


CORPORATIONS – appeal from liability and penalty – challenge to declarations of contravention, imposition of pecuniary penalties and a disqualification order – misleading representation concerning composition of company revenue – effect of representation on existing market understanding and traded share price – continuous disclosure contraventions – materiality decision to terminate commercially significant payment-scheme relationship and reasons given for termination – distinction between disclosure of risk of termination and disclosure that risk had materialised – false or misleading information given to the Australian Securities Exchange – Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 1309(2) – answers to questions considered in context – whether materially false or misleading, including by omission – whether officer took reasonable steps to ensure information was not false or misleading – directors’ duty of care and diligence – involvement in continuous disclosure contravention – ss 674(2A) and 79 – requirement of actual knowledge of essential facts constituting primary contravention – primary contravention constituted by omission to disclose – making and falsity of separate representation not essential facts of non-disclosure contravention – reliance on legal advice – scope and factual basis of advice – distinction between legal assistance in drafting disclosures and advice that disclosure satisfied statutory obligations – relief from liability under ss 1317S(2) and 1318(1) – successive statutory questions – whether person acted honestly – whether person ought fairly to be excused – only if both conditions satisfied, whether relief should be granted – honesty assumed in appellant’s favour – whether person ought fairly to be excused is a value judgment attracting correctness review – ultimate decision whether to grant relief discretionary – person ought not fairly to be excused – discretion to grant relief not reached – pecuniary penalties and disqualification – appellate review of discretionary orders – reliance on legal advice – course of conduct and totality – duration of contraventions – whether anterior factual error materially affected discretionary orders – no appealable error established – declaration of contravention – declaration retained alternatives involving actual knowledge and intentional misconduct not reflected in findings as explained in penalty judgment – declaration overexpansive – appellate power to set aside and replace declaration – correction did not disturb substantive liability, penalty or disqualification – limited factual error established under separate ground but no appellate relief warranted in respect of that error – appeal allowed only to the limited extent necessary to set aside and replace declaration – appeal otherwise dismissed.