Catchwords:
TAXATION – appeal from judgment of primary judge dismissing taxpayer’s appeal in part – where taxpayer entered into contract for disposal of CGT asset in 2019 Year – where taxpayer disposed of asset in 2023 Year – where taxpayer deemed to have disposed of asset in 2019 Year by s 104-10(3) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) – where taxpayer erroneously included a capital gain in tax return for 2020 Year – where notice of assessment for 2020 Year erroneously included a capital gain – where Commissioner sought to amend notices of assessment for 2019 Year and 2020 Year – whether scheme of income taxation imposed by Income Tax Act 1986 (Cth) precluded amendment of 2019 Year assessment unless 2020 Year assessment was also amended – whether s 6-25 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) applied – whether effect of conclusive evidence rule in Sch 1, s 350‑10 of Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) was to preclude amendment of 2019 Year assessment without amendment of 2020 Year assessment – whether amendment of erroneous assessment for 2020 Year necessary for “purpose of giving effect to” s 104-10(3) – appeal dismissed – cross-appeal dismissed.
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – whether any part of statutory scheme of income tax legislation is not a “law with respect to taxation” – whether exercise of judicial power involved – whether s 75(v) of the Constitution guarantees a “right” to contest tax liability.