Recent Cases

TESA Group Pty Ltd v Mining and Energy Union [2026] FCAFC 86 (03 July 2026) (Bromwich, Kennett and Horan JJ)


Catchwords:


PRIVILEGE – parliamentary privilege – where appellant sought recusal of Deputy President of the Fair Work Commission – where Deputy President was a Member of Parliament and shadow cabinet before being appointed to the Commission – where Deputy President dismissed recusal applications and appellant sought judicial review of the dismissal decisions – where case for recusal before the primary judge and on appeal relied upon Hansard extracts containing comments and question made by the Deputy President during parliamentary proceedings – whether s 16(3) of the Parliamentary Privileges Act 1987 (Cth) applied to preclude the admission of the Hansard extracts into evidence – whether s 16(3) should be read down by reason of implications drawn from Ch III of the Constitution – HELD: Hansard extracts should not have been admitted into evidence