Recent Cases

The King v Tsalkos [2025] HCA 49 (03 December 2025) (Gageler CJ; Gordon, Edelman, Steward, Gleeson, Jagot and Beech-Jones JJ)


Catchwords:


Criminal practice – Directions to jury – Distress evidence – Where respondent found guilty of offences against two complainants – Where evidence of pre-trial distress when one complainant made complaint – Where trial judge gave directions in relation to evidence of complainant’s distress – Whether trial judge’s directions invited jury to use distress evidence as independent support for complainant’s account – Whether directions occasioned substantial miscarriage of justice – Whether Court of Appeal’s reasoning contrary to R v Churchill (a pseudonym) (2025) 99 ALJR 719; 422 ALR 265 – Whether evidence inadmissible under s 137 of Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) – Whether miscarriage of justice because prosecutor described distress evidence as “independent evidence”.

Words and phrases – “alleged offending”, “capable of supporting”, “causal connection”, “circumstantial evidence”, “corroboration”, “credit”, “direction”, “distress evidence”, “hearsay rule”, “historical evidentiary rules”, “independent evidence”, “indirect evidence”, “pre-trial distress evidence”, “probative value”, “sexual offence”, “substantial and compelling reasons”, “substantial miscarriage of justice”, “unfair prejudice”, “unreliable”, “weight”.