Recent Cases

Tok v Rashazar [2025] NSWCA 94 (07 May 2025) (Payne, Kirk and Stern JJA)


Catchwords:


CONTRACT – remedies – damages – measure of damages – contract for the sale of shares – where primary judge assessed damages by reference to lost expenditure – where breach results in uncertainty or difficulty of proof of loss – no error in primary judge’s approach

CONTRACT – remedies – damages – time of assessment – where purchase price was paid but shares were not transferred in accordance with the contract – where respondents were unaware that shares were not transferred – no error in assessing damages by reference to events that occurred after the breach of contract

RESTITUTION – ineffective transactions – general principles – restitution of money paid – failure of consideration– where parties’ relationship was governed by a valid contract – subsidiarity principle – where restitutionary claim did not undermine the parties’ allocation of risk